From Plein Air to the Studio

Just Before the Rain, Seminole Island
11 x 14" Oil
~~~
Just Before the Rain didn't always look that good!
I took this piece through several changes!
Can you see the differences?

Plein Air Version Studio Version
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Which do you prefer, and why?
Or, are you like me, there are nice things about both?
~~~~~~~~~
FIVE MAJOR DIFFERENCES
THAT I FOUND.....
#1
The plein air version has a pinkish shade in the cloud reflections in the water.
I do like that. And, that's actually a non-issue because each of these
were photographed under different lighting. The cloud
reflections were never ever pink.
~~~
#2
The plein air version is darker over all because of the lighting used
when photographed. I dislike the darker version. Another non-issue.
~~~
#3
So, now that the non-issues are out of the way, the first thing that
disturbed me about the plein air version were the line of boulders and
rocks. This seemed too unnatural, all the shapes were too much the same
size and coloring, the angle of these shapes was boring, not enough
variation. So, in the Studio Version, you'll see I greatly varied the sizes, the colors,
and the placement of the shapes, moving some up onto the shore, and some
into the water (which is really the way they are in real life).
I also added some grasses into this area, which helped to
ground the shapes.
~~~
#4
The trees were just too green for me in the plein air version.
There was a nice variety of greens, but trees have other colors, not just green.
So, I mixed up some Ultramarine Blue and Titanium White.
I placed that in the tops and a few edges of the trees.
To balance the entire piece,
I also carried that same color into the water a bit.
I think the addition of this color mix added
a nice softness to the painting overall.
~~~
#5
The final aspect of change was the land.
I felt it needed to be a bit brighter green.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Please leave your thoughts below!
What things did you notice that were different?
And, finally, do you see something in the Studio Version
that I might still need to change?
If I agree with you,
I'll definitely make yet another change!
~~~
Thanks for reading!
See you next time!
Donna
Leave a Comment